When attempting to establish the defining moment in the development of the modern musical, few people would disagree when presented with the example of Show Boat...
Written by Oscar Hammerstein II and Jerome Kern, the production was the first major shift from the preceding lighter musical comedies of the time to the musical play, which saw a more wholesome integration of song, humour and dance into a single artistic entity with a much more consistent and credible storyline. It proved to be immensely successful, with both critics and audiences alike.
Unsurprisingly, other examples of this newly established genre emerged, such as Of Thee I Sing!, Cat and the Fiddle and Pal Joey, but none were as epic as the first of the Rodgers and Hammerstein masterpieces Oklahoma!
Oklahoma! firmly established the musical play as a significant art form. It was also notable for defying musical conventions, for example raising its first act curtain with a woman churning butter as opposed to a stage full of dancing chorus girls. It’s initial run lasted 2, 212 performances and was later made into a hit film. It remains one of most frequently produced of the duo’s projects. After Oklahoma! Rodgers and Hammerstein became the most significant contributors to the musical play, with such masterworks as The King and I, South Pacific, Carousel and The Sound of Music. The examples they set in creating works often rich with thought provoking storylines gave encouragement for other gifted writers to create musical plays of their own, Lerner and Loewe, Frank Loesser, Leonard Bernstein and Stephen Sondheim can all count Rodgers and Hammerstein as a significant influence in their respective works.
The 1950s saw a continuation of fine musical plays, My Fair Lady, an adaptation of George Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion starring Rex Harrison and Julie Andrews, which at 2, 717 performances held the longest run record for many years. The Boy Friend ran for 2, 078 performances in London, becoming the third-longest running musical in West–End or Broadway history. The decade ended with Rodgers and Hammerstein’s last hit, The Sound of Music. It ran for 1, 443 performances and shared the Tony Award for Best Musical. Together with its extremely successful 1965 film version, it has become one of the most popular musicals in history.
It must be said, that whilst the musical play continued in its ascendance, the musical comedy did not fall by the wayside. More devoted to escapism and entertainment, musical comedy grew increasingly sophisticated, subtle, and imaginative. Perhaps one of the most notable examples is Guys & Dolls, based on several short stories by Damon Runyon, the show still proves immensely popular with theatre audiences of today.
More recent eras have seen diverse forms of musical theatre flourish: Hair, Jesus Christ Superstar and Tommy are all good examples of 70’s rock music being a dominant theme in the orchestration. The 80’s and 90’s saw the emergence of pop influenced scores involving larger casts and with the advances in stage and set design, the production of musicals has become more complex, involving intricate scene changes and special effects.
Today, familiarity has been embraced by producers, perhaps influenced by the anxious need to ensure that they recoup the considerable investments required to stage a production. A producer will occasionally rise to the challenge of taking on the new and unusual, such as Avenue Q, which utilises puppets to tell an adult themed story. It is becoming increasingly common to see revivals of more traditional shows like Fiddler on the Roof and Guys & Dolls.
Writers also seem more inclined to base their work around previously established works. Films such as Billy Elliot, The Producers and Hairspray have all made the transition to the stage musical, whilst productions such as The Scarlet Pimpernel, Dracula and Wicked have been adapted from popular literary works.